Really more of a 3.5/5 in my opinion. Really great atmosphere in one of Madison's coolest neighborhoods. Sandwiches are pretty good, and most of the ingredients are fresh and well-prepared which elevates this place above your typical sandwich shop. The Gazpacho was amazing as well. 5/5 on that front.
$10 for a cup of soup and a sandwich with a nantucket nectar seems reasonable to me. I'll enjoy this again on a lazy summer afternoon.