I really wasn't impressed. I had read such good reviews and had high hopes, but I didn't think the food or service was all that great.
What was great? The fact that this used to be an old store of some sort and they put tables in the front windows, which make it a great place to people watch. The other awesome thing was the fact they showed "Another Stakeout" in the bar. Yes, that amazing piece of cinematography staring Richard Dreyfuss, Emilio Estevez, Rosie O'Donnell and Dennis Farina (RIP).
Anyway, I ordered a drink to start. It was a "Spring Fling" and was a strawberry like cocktail with basil and vodka. It was ok. It had a very vinegar like taste to it... Not worth the $12 I spent on it.
On to my entree.. Given I was in Ohio, near Lake Erie, I had to get the walleye. Duh...I will say it was delicious. Very fresh. Well cooked. The skin nice and crispy and I loved the kalmata olive puree/sauce it was served with. Not too salty, but a perfect contrast to the freshness of the fish. The thing that that irks me was that was all it was.. A piece of fish. No side dish to mention. No vegetable, really. It came with a couple of inedible brussel sprouts (rock hard, you could barely cut them with a knife) and a small red potato that were quartered. The fish was great, but I was still really hungry after.. So I ordered dessert. That was the best part of the meal.
I followed other Yelpers instructions and ordered the Buttered Popcorn Pot De Creme. It was AWESOME! It's basically a small dish (but filling) of creme brulee with caramel sauce and sea salt on top. It was delicious. My mouth is watering as I write this. I also ordered a cappuccino, which was delicious.
Overall, I ended up spending $75 on a meal I thought was ok, at best.
It didn't really live up to the hype I was hoping for. There are a lot of other restaurants in that area to try out.