As a first-time visitor, I thought the Athenian was a wonderful, unexpected find, especially among the modestly-priced class. I quite enjoyed the falafel pita, while my wife equally enjoyed a chicken platter, both graced with the restaurant's spin on Greek fries.
Two other factors went into this very favorable experience: 1--the unobtrusive, pleasant back ground music, and 2--our waiter, Collin, who was attentive, accurate, and personable.
We'll most assuredly return.