I've been to Color Me Mine multiple times since the store opened a few years ago. The staff is always friendly and the owner, Genny, is definitely a cool cat. Some of the other reviews I've read don't make too much sense at times. The store provides customers with over 60 different paint colors to choose from and around 8 different brush and sponge sizes.
I think the store is much neater, more organized, and cleaner than As You Wish because the associates get the paint for the customers, clean up after them, and tend to them when they need it.
There are literally hundreds of items to choose from to paint, from plates and mugs, to banks and figurines, to vases and frames, to garden and pet pieces.
I also love the fact that Color Me Mine has parties and a separate room to have parties in if the guests choose too. It's bright and fun inside the store, and I've never been to a better paint-you-own-pottery studio ever.
Highly recommended!