I guess I got spoiled.
The Whitewater, WI location is leagues above this location, and it's unfortunate because I used to love going to Rocky's when we lived there.
In three visits to this location after moving to the Middleton area, I've had my order incorrect all three times, and each instance took at least an hour or more. Whether it was an incorrect order slip, or having my pizza given to someone else, it's going to make it difficult for me to ever go back to this location. Each time I also requested wheat crust, but each time we were deceived... we always wound up with the regular crust.
I'm not trying to hate on these guys because they did try to make it up to us by giving us a free pizza... but unfortunately that free pizza order was the one that was given to another customer by accident.