We ordered a slice at the Brimley location in Scarborough and was not impressed.
We decided to give the chain another chance because of good experiences I've had with the brand at work and also thinking that a fresh order would improve the experience.
This little plaza was quite dead when we came on a Saturday on Thanksgiving weekend near 5:15 pm. We actually thought it was closed and the food court was but Reginos was open.
We did a $10.99 large 3-topping walk-in pick up with two dipping sauces. They said it was okay to order 2 different sets of 3 toppings which was nice as it let us try two pizzas for the price of one.
The pizza was ready in 15 minutes. We tried a little in the car and it was great but unfortunately we had to take it home which was 20 minutes away, so it cooled down when we got it back to the house. However, a few minutes in the toaster oven revived it well.
Once properly reheated and piping hot, it was great. I'm sure if we ate it right there and then it would have been delicious as well. We were looking for something tasty and we definitely got that.
It did not blow me away but this is an excellent pizza place at a decent price. We don't eat pizza often but given the price and our previous experience, we will definitely be a repeat customer.
I still would not expect anything fresh if you buy a slice from any pizza place. It might still be good as next-day heated-up pizza which can be just as good as the day of, but it probably has been sitting around longer than you wish.