Have been to a few comedy shows here, and have loved every visit. The theater is nearly perfect in setup - I've been seated near the front, in the very back, and on the loge - not a bad seat in the house. Drink and bar food prices are decent (not so much for Pickwick & Frolic, but that's another review). The food is just your standard bar fare, nothing to rave about, but you don't go there for the food.
The service has always been stellar - even when it's a packed house. I've even been part of a party that unfortunately included a psycho drama queen who stormed into the kitchen crying about something unrelated to the venue, and still, the staff was nothing but gracious and friendly (well, to the rest of us at least).
I've seen comedy shows in about 15 different venues over the years, and Hilarities is easily my favorite overall, and they manage to continue to bring good shows to town.