Stumpy's has been our go-to place for years. I remember when they first opened and I'd take my small kids over to watch them make our pizza. The service has always been wonderful and they make a great pizza. Our favorite happens to be the works: topped with fresh ingredients, sausage, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms. Yum! They know me by name, know what we like, and always have a great big smile for us when we come in to pick up our order (even though they deliver, I enjoy going in to see everyone).
UPDATE: Stumpy's is still offering wonderful pizza and subs. They have added delivery within a certain area, but I still like to go to say hello and watch my pizza come out of the oven. Fridays are busy, so don't be surprised if you have a bit of a wait, but it is well worth it, as they make everything from scratch.