My first experience at CiCi's pizza was very good. After reading mixed reviews, I was pleasantly suprised.
Me and my roommate went in for lunch Sat 3/7/15. For the two of us, 2 buffets and 2 large drinks came to $17.
The place has a family atmosphere and there is also an arcade area. There are tv's around, and on that particular day they had on a soccer game.
There is a salad area, a soup area, and the pizza area. I noticed that the pizzas were always well stocked. The soups weren't anything special- clam chowder and chicken noodle mostly broth but I prefer that anyways. The salad bar had no cheese, and only iceberg lettuce. But they did have mushrooms. And their signature Italian dressing tasted similar to Olive Garden!
As far as the Pizza, I really enjoyed it. I thought the sauce was excellent, and it was fresh. There was a lot of cheese and various toppings. One very cool thing is that you can request a pizza to be made to order. My roommate really liked that--he even got a Pan crust! I posted a picture of it.
Also the drink station has sweet and unsweetened tea. The ice is crushed.
Would I return? Yes absolutely. It's a damn good price and I mean the food is not bad at all!