The beer selection is great. So if you're coming here for take-out beer or sit at the bar, consider it five stars. If you're coming here to eat, you never know what you're going to get.
The buffalo chicken dip is consistently amazing. Best item on the menu. Everything else however is hit or miss. Sometimes the wings are good. The pizza is okay, though they have a creative variety. The gadzooks are very doughy and you miss a lot of the zucchini. It's almost like biting into straight fried batter. Everything just seems... "meh". Sometimes I love what I get, other times I'm not so impressed.
The most consistent part about coming here is that we rarely get a good server. They tend to disappear, not refill drinks, take forever to get the check/cash out, rarely check in. This has been consistent for at least a few years, and not typically friendly.
The best part about this place is when the weather picks up their outdoor patio is perfect for hanging out with a group of friends and having a few beers. There's tons of tvs, inside and out. It's a great bar atmosphere, but the restaurant is, eh.
TL;DR, grab yourself some brewskis and buffalo chicken dip. Everything else is hit or miss.