OK, so a restaurant that is perched on the fountain at the Bellagio automatically gets 2 stars; they could have a horrible staff and only serve cow manure and it would get a two.. I mean just plug your nose, sit quiet, and watch the fountain. That being said, despite the obvious benefits of the setting, I wasn't incredibly impressed with this place, especially given that the bar for dining is a little higher in Vegas in general. Don't get me wrong, it was good food, good service, and I have no big complaints... it just didn't WOW me - and who isn't looking to get "wow'ed" in Sin City? With so many amazing places to go in this town, it may be hard to get me to come back here. I would recommend to a Vegas first timer who wants to picture themselves sitting next to Danny Ocean by the fountain after pulling off that big heist - it's a very "Vegas" experience that everyone should have. Not sure I would recommend if you can't get a spot on the patio, though - in that case you're just in a pretty good but pricey Italian restaurant and may as well be in Pittsburgh.
Only actual complaint was they couldn't get the speaker volume right on the patio, they must have turned it up then down 5 times in the course of the meal per people's complaints/requests.