The name alone evokes the memories of a pubescent boy in rural Ohio tending to the family herd. The burgers, on the other hand, remind me of that mislabeled can of corn in the pantry that turns out to be lima beans!
Honestly, the "Voted Best Burger in Cleveland" label printed on their menu is not exactly what they meant. What I think they meant to say (and would likely be more accurate) was; "We would like to be the Best Burger in Cleveland but can't quite cut the mustard because we serve chewy flavorless bacon with cheap cheese and forgot where we put the salt so our meat couldn't ever win the contest and we think all of the people in Cleveland that did not vote for us are wrong so we print it on our menus anyway." The burgers are okay, but certainly not "award winning". The service was almost as good as the burgers. The fries, however, weren't bad at all!
To be fair, the burgers at the Harry Buffalo (giggles) were ranked #4 in 2010, #5 in 2014, and #7 in 2015 on Cleveland's Hot List (what happened to 2011, 12, 13?) and, last I checked, none of those places are considered "best" unless those ahead of you actually get forced off of a cliff by some Indians! facebook.com/foodiepebbles