This was our first time ordering here. I was hoping it would be worth it. We were so disappointed. This is the least authentic Italian food I've ever had. We ordered through Ubereats....Baked Rigatoni, Garlic Bread w/ Cheese and Pinwheels with pepperoni and extra cheese. What a waste of $35. I took before and after pics...first impression and after we actually dug in.
First of all, there was nothing baked about the rigatoni. The sauce was watery and the cheese was just melted on top. The "garlic bread" was basically a sub roll with cheese melted on top, and I'm pretty sure there was no garlic anywhere near it. The pinwheels would have been decent if the cheese used wasn't so salty and if the bread had been cooked through...literally raw dough inside. We ended up throwing eve. Please see the pics...you can't make this stuff up. Needless to say, I will never be ordering from here again.
**Response to Mike: Thanks for responding. The mere fact that you said "you don't know what other baking could be done" to the Rigatoni is odd to me. Maybe you're right about the missing ricotta b/c there definitely wasn't any in there, but even if it had been, the sauce was so loose and watery that I fear it would have produced the same or at least a similar result. The "garlic sub roll" could have at least had garlic on it! The Pinwheels literally had uncooked dough inside....forget a/b the fact that they were salty. I said in my review that the saltiness was from the type of cheese used. I still stand by everything said in my review, and I, too, wish I had a better experience with Libretto's. Unfortunately, I did not. Thanks again for responding though.