I've tried the Captain's Boil at the North York location prior to visiting the one downtown. Both are identical in terms of the food and menu offerings. Overall, the flavours were consistent and not too overpowering. I've tried the shrimp, clams, crab legs, and many cobs of corn, all of which were generous portions.
Only downside to my recent visit was this unattractive, unappealing, and a bit daunting, yellow sign that was posted on their door upon entry to the restaurant. A conditional health and safety pass.
Hopefully that'll get fixed up upon their next inspection.