Just moved here, and wandered into Smedley's based on the recommendation of a old Navy guy. For those turned off by smoking, it no longer happens and the bar is smoke-free. Food is extremely reasonable, and very good. Beer/alcohol is reasonable as well. As has been noted, crowd tends to ex-military (bar is named after famous Marine Corps general), bikers, cops, but lots of good regular people too and is very friendly. They've had some good bands on the nights we've been there -- almost surprisingly so.
It's exactly the kind of place I was looking for - even though I didn't even know I was looking -- so it's five stars for me. If you're looking for trendy, or a pickup spot for 20-somethings, this isn't it. Not pretentious -- just a good place for good food and beers, good music, and no hipster attitudes.
Ooh-rah.