I must admit, this is my favourite brewery in terms of beers so this is slightly biased from that. In fact I'm sipping a Boneshaker as I write this review! The menu is great, and puts a large scale spin on on pub food. This place has some amazing wings and barbecue, and the entire menu has beer pairings which is FANTASTIC. Personally I choose what kind of beer I'm going to drink and then select my food based on that... I guess that shows what my priorities usually are when I'm at Amsterdam Brewhouse! The staff is also very friendly and energetic and pay the right amount of attention without being ever present.
When you're looking for a brewery experience, especially for people visiting Toronto... this is where to go!