I've been to The Greene House quite a few times and I'm extremely torn on the review, hence the 3 star rating. I think the decor is really nice as its low key and I like the layout of the restaurant. We've never had an issue with service here which is great because that is one of my biggest pet peeves when it comes to dining out.
In my opinion the food is inconsistent from a flavor standpoint. Sometimes they hit the mark (salads, tacos, fish & chips), and others, like the last meal I ate there (Parmesan Gnocchi) just don't. It was pretty bland, sauce and all, so I had to add quite a bit of seasoning with salt and pepper to amp it up.
As my friend Eric once said, "Butter and salt are the reasons the food tastes so good at your favorite restaurant." Seasoning is key and Greene House just missed the mark for me on my last experience. However, I will be back to give GH another shot...60% isn't a failing grade and I know for a fact there are things I do really enjoy about this place.