Great ambience and good service... Food is disappointing.
As someone with serious gluten sensitivity, I rely on protein-friendly menus. Most restaurants are good about this and offer protein wraps (lettuce wrapped around your meat like a bun). This is usually easy and safe.
Unfortunately, Island isn't up with the times. When i expressed my gluten sensitivity, I asked for a lettuce wrap and a side salad with no croutons rather than fries. I received a paper thin patty with the heel end of iceberg lettuce on the top and a side salad loaded with croutons. Under the iceberg lettuce was the tiniest patty I've ever seen... It was more like a mini slider so definitely not filling. My husband had a regular burger and his party was the same. His burger was all bread and he said his fries were tasteless. I expressed this to the server who just said "sorry" and walked away.
The prices are high for such meager amounts. I was really surprised. Their website resembles nothing of what you really get. Quite disheartening.
Needless to say, this is probably a great place to hang out and grab a beer and watch the game but not a place we will return.