I would probably, if able, give them 2.5 stars. We have tried both thin and stuffed. Our 2 experiences had both good and bad.
First, the good: I like the crust. It had good flavor and a nice crispness. The sauce is quite tasty. And the fresh veggies are delicious.
The bad: Let me start by saying that I'm originally from Chicago. So I hold all pizza establishments to a high standard. One of the most important things, for me, on a pizza is the sausage. Both of the pizzas we've had included sausage. The stuffed was just sausage and the thin had green pepper, mushroom, red onion and, supposedly sausage and pepperoni. I say "supposedly," because both were finely ground and were practically nonexistent. I almost had to use a magnifying glass to find any visible proof that they weren't forgotten. And there was no evidence in the taste. If I'm going to shell out $20 + I expect to taste the ingredients for which I've paid. I also think they were a bit skimpy on the cheese. Pizza is all about the cheese. This simply didn't have enough cheese. I used to be in management at a pizza place, so I know how much it actually costs to make a decent pie. AJ'S definitely did not give anything close to my money's worth for either pizza. That being said, I cannot recommend this establishment. Too bad, I had high hopes.