I actually think this restaurant deserves a 3-1/2, but that's not possible. The food is good and the atmosphere is good, but it's quite expensive for what you get (especially for drinks) and I found that the service was mediocre.
We had quite a large group, so we got a variety of pizzas and split them. This was tricky because the pizzas were all divided into four pieces each. Even though we said we were splitting them all, no one seemed to think to split them up a bit more.
They were also quite slow with the service, especially taking our order initially.
But, as I said, the pizzas we ordered were very good. Some stranger combinations were a big hit, like the pear pizza, which worked a bit like a dessert.
The atmosphere is nice, I especially like the basement. So overall if you're looking for a nice night out, I would go for it. If you're looking to just find a good place to eat on a whim, or just because, maybe not.