I think Italian Ice is a stretch, based on what I grew up eating on the East Coast. That said, I came for the custard, which is pretty good.
Two stars, though, is because the floor was so sticky it felt like it hadn't been mopped in a week and every table in the place had something spilled and left on it. For a while. Even the ones outside.
I attribute it to the two teenage boys running the place tonight. Having a teenage boy, I understand just how oblivious they can be to things like cleaning.