I should say that barbeque isn't something I usually go out of my way for. But I'm ALWAYS willing to be convinced. And Old Carolina certainly didn't convince my husband and I. Numerous issues can be raised... from terrible customer service... to weird setup of the restaurant itself. And of course the food that was simply "meh". We paid $24.94 for a brisket sandwich and Brunswick stew for me and a pulled pork with coleslaw sandwich and mac and cheese for my hubby. The sandwiches come with NOTHING else on them which we didn't know. And there are a handful of condiments you can add yourself, but we didn't see them and weren't told. We DID find the barbeque sauces though... none of which really tasted like anything beyond what we could get at Giant Eagle. So while both of our sandwiches weren't bad... they certainly weren't good. The buns are clearly generic and couldn't stand up to the sandwiches. my Brunswick stew was NOT Brunswick stew... it was are cup with mashed tomatoes and corn and pulled chicken with no liquid... and it had no real flavor beyond tomato. My hubby says his mac and cheese was more or less Velveeta on flavor and texture. Processed and nothing special. All in all I feel like we overpaid. Especially considering the HORRIBLE customer service. There was only 2 other couples in the WHOLE dining room... take a second to say Hello and smile. We don't plan on returning.