Brooklyn South is a bit of an enigma to me. Their Italian dishes, like lasagna or chicken parmesan are generally pretty good but not stellar. The pizzas are SO hit or miss. When they are hit they are really good with crisp crust, good sauce and cheese but when they are miss, and they too often are, you wind up with a soggy in the center pos.
Still, for a quick, close to home, relatively inexpensive way to meet an Italian food craving, Brooklyn South fits the bill. Just have the pizza stone ready at home in case you get a soggy one to go!