Prices are very expensive, but the quality is great. Unfortunately, there are other less expensive alternative options in the area with just as great of quality and more variety. Sixteen dollars for two medium turtle pecan custards are just too pricey when there is fierce custard competition in the area. They don't offer turtle pecan custards, so it is considered a "custom" custard. Still, for a two ingredient medium custard, Andy's is overhyped and overpriced. PS. Husband was a fan of the hot fudge