I've lived in the neighbourhood for years and have driven by this place without giving it a second thought. After seeing the stellar yelp reviews, I decided to give it a shot. We ordered a large caesar salad and the L.P. pizza, with hot peppers and extra mushrooms, and left out the green olives and anchovies.
The caesar salad description has a bunch of stuff including bacon bits in the description but it's really only lettuce, dressing and croutons.
The pizza was decent but nothing special at all. I would say it's slightly better than Pizza Pizza and that's not saying much as far as I'm concerned. The crust was nothing special. It didn't taste like cardboard necessarily, but also didn't taste much better than that. There were ample topics but it just didn't come together the way I would have hoped. Overall, it was mediocre.
We did decide to eat in on a nice spring weeknight. They had the door open and the delivery guy came back and put the hockey game on, so not a bad environment.