We just happened upon this place when looking for a coffee shop. Saw the sign for Carl's cakes - which is now the home to Heritage Bakery & Cafe. It was lunch time so we ordered sandwiches, and may I say they were amazing. I had the chicken salad - on wonderful bread, and my husband had the hot ham sandwich. For sides we had the spinach salad - so good! - and the pasta salad, ate every bit. The baked goods looked wonderful and we took cookies to go. Everything was really delicious and I would go out of my way to stop there again next time I'm in Madison.