This is hands down the best local pizza I've ever had. I'm not trying to say it will beat places like Settebello or Grimaldi's, because I wouldn't really consider those a "local pizza shop." Those places are specialty type places, and the prices match that luxury. Joey's has an XL 1-topping pizza for like 12 bucks. Get a pepperoni cooked well done and you will be so happy, you won't know what to do with yourself. Their wings are also fan-freaking-tastic. I would recommend getting them dry with the sauce on the side, but I would always recommend that for to-go wings; it really cuts down on the soggy factor, which I think gives many places an unfair shake. Their ranch is exquisite, and I never get the pizza without it. The mushrooms on the pizza are fresh, and really taste like mushrooms. Ordering almost anything to-go takes them 15 minutes, and I've never had to wait more than a few minutes if they had a rush. Seriously, anyone who doesn't like their pizza doesn't like NY style pizza, caught them on a bad day (which has never happened to me after ordering at least 20 times), expects things from a PIZZA place that you shouldn't (chicken fingers? Go to KFC for that), or should really just stick to places like California Pizza Kitchen. For those of us who like folding their pizza, having excellent quality cheese with excellent quality grease, you can't go wrong with Joey's.
P.S. Look at the pictures; even when people didn't like the pizza, it looks amazing. And it tastes just as good as it looks. Best crust in town, maybe. Seriously.