So - I've waited to write this review until I had tasted a fair number of items from this bakery near our house. At this point - I've got enough to give my assessment.
The good: their brownies are pretty decent and I've served them at a party with good success.
The average: Their cookies are so-so. I've had better for less money. Specifically, the sugar cookies are too hard on the outside compared to how soft they are on the inside and the other cookies I tasted were all far too sweet.
The bad: Lastly - the cupcakes (which is what we all care about). They're average. The salted caramel is the best I've had of their flavors (and yes, I've pretty much tasted them all). The salty peanut butter caramel one would be good - but twice when we've tried it, the pretzels on top have been stale (which is gross). The vanilla is ok, but really too sweet and not enough 'vanilla' flavor. And the double chocolate is good, but again... not great. Most of their icings are too sweet and sugary tasting.
Nothing I've had there is terrible - but nothing blew me away considering how many good bakeries there are in town. I'm sticking with Simply Sweets for my cupcake and cake orders for parties... and we will support some of the other local bakeries for our 'impulse' dessert cravings!