I came here with a Groupon, but still thought it was a pricey meal. My friend and I shared four items (grilled cheese, ricotta cake, eggplant and oyster mushroom) and we went to eat sushi after. Well if the Coal Shed was open we would've ate there after instead. The food itself wasn't bad, but it wasn't that great either, and I don't find any dish overly creative or anything. Some flavors were good while others clashed. But seriously... the price. $68 for two people and we needed more food after. It's only vegetables. Why $18 for mushrooms + egg + potato?
Just on the food alone I would only rate it three stars, but the service was pretty decent, albeit slow.
I also found it interesting that they have pescatarian add-ons.