As a vegan, I can't honestly review the food here since it is very "meat and potatoes"--think classic Wisconsin Supper Club food but dressed up for the hip Madison Crowd who would otherwise look down their nose at this style of cuisine. I'm rating this as a bar. Their beer selection is solid--not as good as say, the Malthouse--but pretty good. And the pours are affordable. I recommend coming here and doing a couple of sampler rounds with friends, ordering a big plate of fries and just people-watching on the square. It gets really crowded though, which is lame, and suffers from a really bad faux-smoke smell that might bother you.