Stopped by close to closing time so we didn't expect too many flavours to be left. We got a cookie dough ice cream sammie and a milk and cookie combo. The milk and cookie combo was the better pick in my opinion. The cookies and cream cookie matched perfectly with the subtle taste of the vanilla bean milk we had paired it with. The ice cream sammie we picked up in addition to this combo? Although the idea is great, this was much, much too sweet. It was monstrous and we probably could have just shared the ice cream treat. The ice cream was just your run of the mill vanilla, very plain Jane. The chocolate chunks in the cookie dough were also large and thick enough to chip your teeth if you weren't careful. If we come back again, I don't think we'll be ordering an ice cream sandwich from them.
Edit: disclosure that we did not finish the ice cream sammie. It was too sweet and much too large. We got sick of it before we could finish.