I thought this would be over-rated like some other ice-cream places in Toronto that have long lineups out the door and around the block, but it surprised me by being actually good. But then again, I'm a fan of soft-serve, and of icing and crazy toppings, so the $6.50 was totally worth it for me, and I would go again.
The line goes pretty fast, actually. A staff member came out and handed out menus, so people could look at options and decide beforehand. Once you get inside, you can see that they're also really efficient at serving -- not so much smalltalk, just pick your ice-cream, pay your money, and out the door. I got the birthday cake because it was actually my birthday, and I love vanilla and birthday cake flavour. Didn't know it comes with a candle and everything, but that was nice. :)
If you're worried you can't finish it: get yours in a cup -- they look smaller than the cones -- and share it with a loved one.