WHAT's GOOD
Nice eccentric hotel with very weird choices in the interiors. The recreation of past times of the college is something that makes this hotel different from any other. Clean rooms with nice space and with balcony access available. Beds are confortable and couldn't hear noises during the night.
What is very nice is the bar in the hotel (Tapacubo) that serves good late night food too and The Normal Diner, open from 7 to 7, very convenient option for breakfast and lunch.
WHAT's BAD
The hotel-bar-restaurant are served by young college/university boys and girls that sometimes even with the good will, they do not seem to be very professional or aware of the job they are doing A general manager present on site would help. Gym is very, very minimal.
FORGET THE DRY CLEAN SERVICE IN THE HOTEL! Outrageously Expensive !!!
I would go back, YES. No Laundry done there