This was our first time at Nonna's. We were pleasantly surprised. The staff was friendly and our waiter Jeff was excellent. My wife chose the eggplant parmesan, I had the stuffed shells, and my daughter had the children's portion of the ravioli. We all shared an order of garlic knots.
Everything was fresh and flavorful. The marinara sauce had a sweet light flavor. My daughter was thrilled that her dish came out first and that they "put kids first". She described her dish as "cheesy!". My wife's eggplant was tasty and the portion big enough that she had leftovers. My shells were properly cooked without being tough or rubbery as will sometimes happen with baked pasta dishes.
The prices are reasonable, the atmosphere is relaxed and friendly. Even though it's not a large restaurant it doesn't seem cramped or crowded. We will definitely come back since they have so many interesting options. I'd definitely recommend Nonna's.