I don't know if I should rate it a 3 or a 4 because I pretty much liked the gelato but not the pistachio cheesecake. I guess I'm just biased because I've been baking my own cheesecakes and I always compare it to my own creations. I did try the same pistachio cheesecake at carole's and theirs was definitely better. I guess they specialized more with the gelatos and not the cakes. They did have the gluten free cheesecake though which was pretty cool.