Craig's Cookies is tucked away deep in Parkdale and may be a bit of a trek for some, but it's well worth the journey. The bright yellow store only opened within the last month or so but has been doing incredibly well.
My first Craig's cookies experience did not disappoint - probably the best cookie I've had in Toronto. They offer a wide selection of unique cookies with various ingredients smashed and baked into the middle - pop tart, mars bars, mint patty, peanut butter cup, rice krispy, you name it. If that isn't enough to sell you, the actual cookies are incredible and are made the way any cookie lover craves - soft, gooey and sweet in the middle.
A must try.