Finally stopped in for happy hour after reading the "five olives" reviews from the Plain Dealer. The place was fancier than I had expected. I did feel somewhat under-dressed in jeans, but I wasn't going to let the "proper attire required" sign on the front door scare me away. The happy hour (3p-6p) deals were pretty good, and especially so considering the prices on the regular dinner menu. $5.50 for a cheeseburger and fries, $2.50 for a Peroni, and they even brought warm bread with pesto butter to the table. The cheeseburger was fine, nothing special. The fries were good.
I could be wrong, but this feels like the kind of place where people only go because they want to impress (business clients, dates, in-laws, etc.), not because they actually want to eat here. I would go back for happy hour since I live so close, but I wouldn't say it's worth going out of your way for, at least for happy hour.