I don't care what people say, the food was incredible. My German native friend recommended the place. It looks a bit mom and pop, which I'm fine with. There are three spaces here; a bar, a store and the restaurant.
me and my bf started with
Bavian Potato Soup - so incredibly good
And a bread dumpling soup - amazing.
Then we shared a Combination Plate #3 for $17.00
Hungarian Debreczinger - rather spicy and good.
Bockwurst - ooo soo so so mouth watering good
Knackwurst - oh so so soft and so good
Our waitress was technically born in Germany but was as american as Apple pie. No biggie, she was sweet and a great hostess!
We bought German Chocolate to take with us, as we were so full.
In writing this review, I realize I have to go back. The food was just that good. And prices were reasonable. Also I found this http://www.citycoups.com/cafeheidleberg.html couple for half off. I'll print it and see if it works. :)