I loved the vibe, and yes I would def. come again.
I went to Comedy Bar on a weeknight. It wasn't packed, but the performances were fun to watch nonetheless.
Audience interaction. Small venue, kind of a dive but nobody seemed to care.
Admission was very reasonable - tickets tend to be $8-$5/person. Length of the show that I went to was a little over an hour.
(p.s. for fellow veg-heads: How fantastic is it that they're veg friendly?! They served more than a token salad or veg soup... Given that their menu isn't as expansive as some non-fast food joints, pretty impressive that close to half of the items were vegetarian).
If the bar is packed, just come back during the show. Won't take long at all to get the bartender's attention then. * Note, the kitchen closes 15 minutes after the start of the last show.
For weekend shows, try to secure tickets in advance; these are the tix that tend to sell out. I found their phone # useless; better to head there in person around 7 pm to buy tickets at least 24 hours in advance.