I went here on high recommendation... I was told that I would want to move from Scottsdale to Chandler to be closer to this restaurant. Well... I am not moving. I did enjoy it though.
First off, I ranked this place a 3, but it's very nearly a 4. My only issue was the grease. Their food is greasy. It's tasty, but greasy. We ordered a small pizza, famous breadsticks with cheese, and baked spaghetti. The baked spaghetti was supposed to be the best thing I've ever eaten. It was good. The breadsticks were good - it would've been nice had we known the baked spaghetti came with breadsticks - we wouldn't have ordered a separate side.
The table was filled with mounds of bread and cheese. We ended up needing 2 or 3 to-go boxes. I had to soak up grease with napkins. The peperoni was flavorful though. The pizza was delicious. It wasn't the best I've ever had, but it was good.
Nothing was bad about this place - it's very much an authentic classic pizza joint. The place was clean (didn't check out the bathroom though) and smelled of pizza. The staff was nice (though they forgot the meat sauce we ordered with our pasta).
If you live in the area, it's a solid choice. If I lived nearby, it would be on rotation. I won't be going out of my way to eat here, but I will eat here again. Nearly a 4 star rating here. I only wish I didn't feel like I just ate a lump of fat and washed it down with a glass full of grease.