I guess this review isn't very "fair" since its from an experience over a year old, but maybe nothing's changed? Perhaps, it has.. Either way, here is my experience..
My boyfriend and I stopped in for dinner around 7pm. He got chicken pasta-something-something and I got the fettucine alfredo (I know--they put this one the menu to point out who's bland when it gets ordered). The bread they brought out was good and the boyfriend even tried to take a loaf of it home, but wound up leaving it on the table. Our meals were good, albeit overpriced for what they were.
The service was good. I cannot, for the life of me, remember our waitress' name, but she was a very sweet girl who made sure glasses stayed full and we stayed happy. Granted, I saw *maybe* two other couples having dinner at that time.
It was a good experience.
Not great... just... good.
Three stars, Macaroni Grill.