I absolutely love this place. I've returned on multiple occasions and have always been impressed by the quality of the items I get. Most of my visits have been for ice cream, milkshake or floats but I've recently started to sample the 'baker' items and I have really been blown away.
Beef pot pie - Ahhmazing. wonderfully rich and flakey crust surrounding what tastes like a rosemary and tomato filling. Plenty of beef and didn't find any pieces with grizzle or fat.
Chicken pot pie - Also Amazing. Traditional pot pie flavour but the flavour somehow seems more intense than other pot pies. I think there are additional seasonings.
Sausage roll - why is this soooo good? The spicing is terrific and there are onions in it. I think she might make her own sausage out of ground pork.
Turkey sandwich - A simple sandwich that was just made well and with care. Fresh bread, deli style turkey meat, toasted on the outside and served with 2 gherkins. I may need to try another since my friend 'tasted' then ate most of it.
Milk chocolate skor cookie - buttery sweet and delicious. A perfect cookie.
Chocolate malted milkshake - I've had this the most of anything (~8 times). I'd recommend getting it in a traditional fountain glass (dine in) so you get the whole shake + the overflow.
Strawberry Hibiscus Float - Yummy and so much fun. A must try.
Chocolate egg cream - This chocolatey soda drink might not be for everyone but I happen to love them. Their technique is very good. They make them with a little more soda water than I would (I tend to use a little more milk) but this is consistent with how other places like the Brooklyn pharmacy make them. This is a very fun drink to get here and I'd recommend trying it if you haven't had one before.
Ice cream cookie sandwich - Quite good, but you can have this anywhere. If this will be your only visit I'd suggest going with something more unique to the place instead.
ice cream cone - same comment as above
Ferrero Rocher Brownie - Not that into this one. The base is good but the nutella, hazelnut and chocolate chunk top had a bit of an odd taste.
In conclusion, you should go here. Also, I want to marry Liezel who is an extremely gifted baker. Too bad for me she is already married.