I was apprehensive about this place because of all the bad reviews, but I'm glad I stopped by and checked it out for myself.
Pugliano's offers your standard neighborhood bar/restaurant fare, with a focus on Italian dishes, steak, and sandwiches. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat there, but the food is tasty and far better than what you'd get at any of the the plethora of chain restaurants in the Monroeville/Murrysville area.
The bar offers a good selection of beer, wine, and cocktails, and each time I've had a cocktail they've been well made without skimping on the liquor.
Service is okay - a bit slow at times, but the servers are very friendly. My fianceé visited with a few friends, and her server remembered her when we came in weeks later.