We visited MakMak for the first time recently, and were overall pretty happy with the experience. the restaurant is quaint, and the service is great- the waitress was very hospitable and sweet, and helpful when making the menu selection.
The veggie tomyum soup was awesome. it had a good 'kick' to it. I liked the imperial roll as well, but I found it to be a little bland- although I enjoyed the crispiness. I was a little disappointed with the pad thai- the noodles were kind of soggy and the saucy was pretty salty and tasted a bit like ketchup. I know there are different variations of pad-thai, but generally i like mine with the noodles fried a little longer and crispier and the sauce to have a little more going on. I was also dissapointed with the spice-rating- I ordered a 5 (out of 6) and it wasn't spicy at all!
on the whole, I like makmak and i'll probably be back, but I find it a little overpriced considering the magnitude of cheap thai in montreal.