Had the fish and chips for lunch. In all honesty it was just ok, not great. I was hoping for a traditional beer battered filet but they serve it up crunchy seasoned bread style. Don't get me wrong it was tasty but it didn't hit the spot. One of my fish filets was seriously overcooked and was tough and rubbery so i didn't eat it just the yummy bread coating. The fish is served with slightly seasoned chips, aka fries that were yummy, but you really can't mess up on fries. The staff was really friendly and service was awesome. Danny my waiter was great! I do think it was a little overpriced as well for the amount of food you get. Oyster Bay is a hit or miss.