I got killed by chocolate here. Definitely order the sharing for 2 (sampler) for a great first time experience. I've been here twice now and both times I would have rated 4.5.
My second visit, my friend and I shared a pizza and the sampler. More than enough for us and very affordable! We opted for the milk chocolate for our fondue but you had choices from dark chocolate and white chocolate.
My next visit I want to try that smores item! And I can't wait to come back in the winter too.
Edit (08/28/11): This place is definitely one of the better places in Vegas to take on a first date. Which gives me an idea of a new list, where to go on a first date!