Ehhh... We were totally looking forward to this buffet, especially with the lobster tails, but sadly it disappointed. The quality of the seafood was decent, but wasn't superb. For the price of the buffet, you're better off visiting Wynn. Granted they don't have as much seafood as this one, but the quality of the food is three times over way more superb.
If you're staying at a large casino hotel, stop by your concierge for a "what's on las vegas" magazine, there's a coupon in there every other month for a 10 dollars off coupon for this buffet. Now at 24.99, its more of a 4 star buffet.
Lobster was hit or miss. Some tails were mushy (dead lobster) some where more fresh. Crab was ok, they didn't have dungeness which was a bummer. Oysters were hit and miss too. The upside was that the dessert was awesome, but not worth the 34.99 price tag or the 24.99 post coupon tag. Definately a place to try out once for the gluttony of eating 29 split lobster tails.