Normally we love Papa John's, but they don't deliver to our place. We really wanted pizza so ordered carryout from what we thought was the Middleton store. Our mistake we ordered from here. That's ok. It was our mistake.
However, this store is insanely hard to find and get to and there is zero parking outside for carryout. We ordered online from another store and the order stated it would be ready in 45 minutes. It gave us a time. It actually took longer than 45 minutes to weave through the square and finally park illegally in an alley behind the store while the husband went to get said pizzas. They were just putting them in the oven. So we had to wait another twenty minutes and staff wasn't apologetic, just rude stating that the pick up time is an estimate.
The pizza was fine. It was fresh and stayed warm on an eighty degree day until we were home to eat it. But....it's not worth the trip and while I gave no real issues with it taking an hour plus to be ready for carryout during a busy time of day that should be acknowledged ahead of time.