I did it! I'm a such a yelper! I went to, and am about to review "Mystic Muffin."
We went in around 2, and they were low on most things, I gather from how awesome they are they are really busy at lunchtime.
We had the falafel plate, a bagel sandwich, beef roll and the infamous apple cake. It was all cheap and delicious. The apple cake was free because it was our first time -- not an urban legend, they actually love giving first-timers free cake.
My dining companion thought the food was good, but not as amazing as everyone said. HOWEVER, he said they were the nicest people in the world so he understands the perfect reviews.
While we were in there they gave away free coffee and cake to homeless people and knew them by name. Really swell people, really nice lunch, really close to moss park for a picnic.