Okay. I'm a HUGE fan of the Nauti Mermaid!
As someone who grew up spending summers in coastal New England, I'm a big seafood guy. So... a bar in Ohio with a seafood theme?? Pretty unique! That alone gives it points in my book.
The service is standard. However, the food is FANTASTIC (although a bit pricey). They have some inspired seafood dishes that you won't find in most places. Portions are VERY big. I ordered standard fish-and-chips last time and it was enough food for 2 easily!
What I love most about this place isn't any tangible thing, it's the PURPOSE the Nauti Mermaid serves. It's in middle of W 6th Street... surrounded by the main Cleveland bars and clubs. It's the perfect place to START your Friday or Saturday night. Go out with some friends, get some drinks, get some food... and then decide if you really want to walk down the street to "party"... or if you just want to keep it low key and stay put.
SUMMARY: Relaxed, low-pressure atmosphere... perfect place to start your night out downtown... great seafood... slightly pricey... funny decor